Why do you on the Left support something that has no basis in logic or science, is largely harmful and whose damage is irreversible?

[WuWei]

@Imel

No they are in a category of their own, not claiming to be woman but trans.
You know the distinction why claim otherwise.

You’re wrong as can be.

[Jezcoe]

@Eagle-Keeper

@Jezcoe

@Eagle-Keeper

@Jezcoe

Lia Thomas is a Trans Woman.

Define trans woman, wait let me: A meaningless term created by lib academics and used by libs to codify a group of mentally disturbed people.

It actually means something.

It is a definition of a real world person and their experience.

So it isn’t meaningless.

What is meant by the term “trans”? Is that in relation to the word “transition”? If so, transition into what?

It isn’t transition but transgender.

[WuWei]

Yes, but “transition” is also in the vocabulary. “Transition” into what?

[bigtwnvin]

Will Thomas was at best an average to below average competitive swimmer competing against men. Only until his declaration of being a tranny and given the opportunity to beat the girls did his name become synonymous with tranny rights in sports. He’s a male period. The girls should boycott but in the end they’re the ones who lose out. As far as the locker room ■■■■ show goes, the girls should beat his ass and kick his fake and phony gender bull ■■■■ out.

[WuWei]

@Imel

No they are in a category of their own, not claiming to be woman but trans.
You know the distinction why claim otherwise.

What NCAA championship did Will Thomas “win.”

What award did Bruce Jenner win in 2015?

Who was USA Today’s Woman of the Year for Minnesota this year?

[Eagle-Keeper]

@WuWei

@Imel

No they are in a category of their own, not claiming to be woman but trans.
You know the distinction why claim otherwise.

What NCAA championship did Will Thomas “win.”

What award did Bruce Jenner win in 2015?

Who was USA Today’s Woman of the Year for Minnesota this year?

Exactly! This movement is not demanding a separate category for them, but are demanding spaces traditionally reserved for biological women, with numerous examples being posted here:

Female athlete complains about competing against transgender males

Is it time for these people to stop crying about this issue and just suck it up?

[Piper]

@Imel

The definition of a man and a woman has not changed but there is a small sub section of each group who feel they belong to the other.

We can’t successfully feel our way through life. Unless we are blind and deaf.

[gooddad409]

@bigtwnvin

Will Thomas was at best an average to below average competitive swimmer competing against men. Only until his declaration of being a tranny and given the opportunity to beat the girls did his name become synonymous with tranny rights in sports. He’s a male period. The girls should boycott but in the end they’re the ones who lose out. As far as the locker room ■■■■ show goes, the girls should beat his ass and kick his fake and phony gender bull ■■■■ out.

Great post. Well said.

[Eagle-Keeper]

@WuWei

@Eagle-Keeper

On the other hand if I as a man say that I like to bake cookies and wear a dress a claim that makes me a woman, would you agree?

Absolutely not

It would appear though that in the views of @Jezcoe & @Imel I then would be classified as transgender.

[Jezcoe]

@Eagle-Keeper

@WuWei

@Eagle-Keeper

On the other hand if I as a man say that I like to bake cookies and wear a dress a claim that makes me a woman, would you agree?

Absolutely not

It would appear though that in the views of @Jezcoe & @Imel I then would be classified as transgender.

Clothes and baking does not make one trans.

If you identified as the gender opposite of what you were born with, then you would be trans.

[WuWei]

@Jezcoe

If you identified as the gender opposite of what you were born with, then you would be trans.

Then there’s only two. Progress!

[Eagle-Keeper]

@Jezcoe

@Eagle-Keeper

@WuWei

@Eagle-Keeper

On the other hand if I as a man say that I like to bake cookies and wear a dress a claim that makes me a woman, would you agree?

Absolutely not

It would appear though that in the views of @Jezcoe & @Imel I then would be classified as transgender.

Clothes and baking does not make one trans.

If you identified as the gender opposite of what you were born with, then you would be trans.

So what are the identifiers required for one to objectively be classified as so-called trans?

[Jezcoe]

@Eagle-Keeper

@Jezcoe

@Eagle-Keeper

@WuWei

@Eagle-Keeper

On the other hand if I as a man say that I like to bake cookies and wear a dress a claim that makes me a woman, would you agree?

Absolutely not

It would appear though that in the views of @Jezcoe & @Imel I then would be classified as transgender.

Clothes and baking does not make one trans.

If you identified as the gender opposite of what you were born with, then you would be trans.

So what are the identifiers required for one to objectively be classified as so-called trans?

Living as the gender that they identify with.

[Oldandtired]

Problem is they cannot live as a woman because they are not a woman. They have no idea what a woman is and it seems neither to you. All they are is a mentally ill male.

[SixFoot]

[Jezcoe]

@Oldandtired

Problem is they cannot live as a woman because they are not a woman. They have no idea what a woman is and it seems neither to you. All they are is a mentally ill male.

I know a few trans people who have no problem living as the gender that they identify with…. So there is that.

[WuWei]

They might identify with their idea of the opposite gender. They have no idea what it actually is.

[thinkingman]

@Jezcoe

@Oldandtired

Problem is they cannot live as a woman because they are not a woman. They have no idea what a woman is and it seems neither to you. All they are is a mentally ill male.

I know a few trans people who have no problem living as the gender that they identify with…. So there is that.

many people are not at odds with their mental maladies.

so there’s that, too

[WuWei]

Any bets?

Oregon middle school won't say whether student filmed attacking smaller girl...

[Eagle-Keeper]

@Jezcoe

@Oldandtired

Problem is they cannot live as a woman because they are not a woman. They have no idea what a woman is and it seems neither to you. All they are is a mentally ill male.

I know a few trans people who have no problem living as the gender that they identify with…. So there is that.

Define what it means to live as “man” and define what it means to live as a “woman.”