And? I wouldn’t have found it odd if a neighbor had popped out and said yeah, he lives there, that they would take their word. Not many burglars go to the trouble of breaking into two house so they can alibi each other.
I show up at 1 am to start three hours of bake (last job) or at 3 am to begin disassembling gondolas (this one) I don’t have to prove I own the keys to my store, or the tools I’m carrying to the job site.
In that particular case, I have already “committed a crime”, so to speak, and the regulations surrounding that encounter with the police are somewhat different.
However, the few times I have been pulled over, I have asked the officer to first spell out what they believe I have done wrong before I show them anything. I am polite but firm on this matter.
In at least two cases they accused me of doing something I did not do and it was easy for me to prove it…in both cases the encounter with the officer ended without me showing them my identification.
Your problem is you believe the officer gets to control the conversation and the narrative.
If you believe in property rights, why would you mind the police enforcing them? If cops get a report of someone breaking into my home, I want them to come, even if it’s me doing the breaking and entering because shocker, they have no way of knowing its the owner until they ask and it is proven. The question is, why should anyone make that confrontational? They are there for the sole reason of protecting your property, the proper response is to be cooperative and thank them.