SCARBOROUGH: “So, we’re checking the story about a child who an immigration lawyer said I think, a news outlet retweeted, that a child may have died in custody. There is no confirmation of that story yet. So, if we get confirmation, we’ll let you know. But right now —
Story initially reported as a child "may have died " = yet unconfirmed
That lead to them coming back with this…
Confirmation received = Story as initially reported that child “may have died” was not correct.
There is no “fake news” in there.
The problem is you can’t help yourself.
You appear to be in some sort of Trump influenced denial.
One of the most famous UK tabloid stories was “Freddie Starr ate my hampster.” Freddie Starr - Wikipedia. The story itself amounted in an unsubstantiated claim by just one person and it would appear that no effort was made to verify any of the alleged facts.
In the absence of any evidence the headline would appear to be entirely misleading. Furthermore it seems entirely reasonable to suggest that the paper the editor and the reporter all knew that the headline was misleading.
And yet, while some people would say this intentionally misleading headline and the unsubstantiated allegation, amount to ‘fake’ news, the story is not ‘fake news’. I believe the papers defence of the story would be that they were accurately report the alleged claim itself and that the paper was not itself claiming that the event occurred.
If, however, the story had contained a false claim by the paper, for example that the reporter had been shown a half eaten hampster, or if the reporter had falsely claimed to have confirmed the story with Mr Starr, then the story would correctly be identified as fake news.
Personally I think the problem with associating the terms ‘tabloid’ or ‘tabloid journalism’ with ‘fake news’ is that it suggests that a tabloid story such as the above example is ‘fake news.’ I would maintain that such tabloid stories have not quite descended to the depths of ‘fake news’. Rather such stories remain at the bottom, in terms of quality, of what can be described as ‘news’.