That was not the decision in this case and I agree with that decision. There was reasonable fear that he was going to go for that gun with a 50% chance of getting it and using it. No cop should be forced to take that sort of chance.
We are horrified by the video we saw, but as a white man, in the last week my black friends really opened my eyes. They told me that this isn’t new for them. This shocks them, but they see this regularly. Just think how many times these events happen without us knowing. Unless we change the culture of cops to hold each other accountable to the degree of getting management involved, we can’t get rid of the bad ones.
Can you imagine the charges I would get if Keeled on someones neck while they screamed for help for 8 minutes in broad daylight? This has to be upped to 2nd or 1st degree.
Of course there are different rules. They don’t have to opportunity the head the other way when they see someone who is committing a violent crime. If they hear a woman screaming from down the hall in their apartment complex, they don’t have the privilege of dialing 911 and feeling they have done their duty.
Can you see why 3rd degree only made people angrier? Made it seem like a cover up was in place. I think first degree can be put on the table. How many times does someone need to be told they are killing someone before its premeditated. Like, he sat the on the ground literally saying, “you are killing me, please, I can’t breathe.” Just hearing that made me so mad.
This is why one thing we need to do is get cops involved with the community more. If helping to build murals or help fix churches were part of the duty it would do a lot of good in repairing that relationship .
Premeditation would require that the officer planned to kill Floyd before he put his knee on his neck.
Second-degree would require proving that the officer intended to kill Floyd.
Third-degree murder - otherwise known as “depraved heart” murder - doesn’t require the prosecution to prove that he intended to kill Floyd, and it’s still murder.