The only options aren’t “a year in jail” and “go free with no consequences.” She got beat up, she spent hours in lockup, she’ll likely be fined, and she’ll have a crime on her record so if she does it again the consequences will be more severe.
You have one source that says one thing. “Read what I link and agree with it, or I will denigrate you…”
Stupid should hurt. As far as I am concerned, that’s all I said. Your article focused on jail. I said nothing about jail. In fact, I actually said:
Your article essentially concluded that jail doesn’t actually “hurt” the perpetrator. (Or at least in the mind of the perpetrator when making the choice, it’s not enough of a cost.)
Stupid should hurt. What the OP was faulting in our current societal approach is that we decide something is not “big enough” to do anything about. We’ve been moving the bar deeper and deeper into the realm of stupid before we do something.
No, it will ruin her life if she has career goals. This is not a crime of such magnitude that her life should be ruined. A fine and a hundred hours of community service followed by expunging her record is far more appropriate
She should have though of that before jumping the wall, she should have thought of that before she wasn’t going to talk to Homeland security and FBI.
A fine, a little jail time, and the record that follows her for a long time is appropriate (I’d like to see the entire year, but my guess would be a month is what she would get.)
It was a prank. A very stupid prank, but a prank nonetheless. And not one a mentally balanced person would do. She needs professional help a lot more than she needs jail time which will only exacerbate her instability.
And the record will not just follow her, it most likely will ruin her life by removing most career paths. Something like that doesn’t just follow you for a limited time. Her life should not be ruined over it.