It’s information pertinent to this thread. Process it how you’d like.
My problem with the tweet is the broad-brushing. “Jewish communities” in the US have different opinions about different things, just like everyone else.
1 Like
No he didn’t. But you latched on to it and made the same wrong claims. Jews are not “white” in the American sense just because they are caucasian. They are “white” if their skin is white.
“White” is a useless physical description.
I will agree that he should have used a different term. That’s as far as I will go.
I will agree that the white descendants of white European Jews have white skin.
Semites come in all colors, as do caucasians. I will not agree that “Jews are white” as a blanket statement.
Anymore than I agree that Hispanicos “are white” as a blanket statement.
What he said about Jews supporting the hatred used against them is correct.
I think we are dancing around of the truth about your claims that the conflict is “about land not Jews.”
There seems to be a major difference between the descendants of European and American Jews and Israeli Jews. I can think of various reasons that might be.
European and American Jews are all screwed up with progressivism, etc. Completely indoctrinated. Always leaned a bit that way anyway.
I can see how an American Jew would separate in their mind Israel and Jewish. I can’t see it to the point of supporting HAMAS “Palestine” over Israel, but I’m not an indoctrinated critprog.
It is a very interesting discussion.
1 Like
Mmmmm. But there are tendencies. “Tends” if you will.
It was definitely broad-brushing. Not necessarily antisemitic.
Is it true?
Yes it is a very interesting discussion.
And your in depth does actually cover very important topics.
I don’t actually disagree with most of that
That being said i am clinging on to his language because his choice of words is important. I am harping on it. Yes.
50 shades of white.
3 Likes
Important to whom why?
Are you clinging to it because it confirms your victimhood bias?
Every one of them with pale skin, blue eyes and blonde hair.
Yes it does confirm my victimhood bias of Jews being isolated by some. Of course. All claims of antisemitism are victimhood. Each and everyone of them.
1 Like
Not even close. 
1 Like
“We’re white!”
What a silly thing to claim.
How can a guy on twitter isolate a nation?
I would offer the Jewish nation has isolated (set apart) itself far more-for reasons both good and bad- for as long as it has existed.
Agreed, they need to be more specific.
Some are porcelain-white.
Some are ginger-white.
Some are bronze-white.
I’m more of a beige-white, depending on the angle of the sun.
1 Like
How can a guy on a college campus support Hamas……. With words of course.
Supporting Hamas is nowhere near isolating a nation. Stop being silly.
That’s very true except for this country and i am not talking about Hasidic communities. Those are still pretty insular.
I didn’t say that it was
Calling Jews not white is as hateful as supporting palesitinians
This country as much if not more than any other.
Jewish progressivism is incompatible with American founding liberalism.
That doesn’t make them isolated.
We are may be talking about different things.
