Fathers rarely need to resort to the belt. I never had to lay a hand on mine, no back talk but they’d give the wife grief. Men are just scarier to children. Couple of slammed doors was the extent of their push back with me. Of course I had it easy with just girls who were people pleasers.
I’m personally against hitting children… so that will color my opinion.
But I think this larger idea that father’s are needed because they are more imposing then mothers I’m finding to be unconvincing. There are soft spoken fathers and loud scary mothers.
Like I said, I never hit mine. My view is if you can’t control children without resorting to hitting them, you aren’t very good at parenting. However, intimidation is fair game, especially with boys. And self defense also has to be on the table with older boys. You don’t find many moms who can bench over 250 though.
My wife and I never do good cop/bad cop… we try to keep a united front, so to speak.
My mom spanked me a few times and slapped me once when I was a teen, but that was because I told her a “Pee-Wee Herman in a movie theater” joke when we were in a church. She was beaten a lot by her father though and while they reconciled when he was much older, it definitely created a split in their relationship.
More stereotypes. They do work differently… but what really makes people more different is their personality not their gender. Men can be nurturing and women can know how to fight. Boys and girls should both be taught to be nurturing AND be able to defend themselves if need be.
Women and men have roles in households and in raising children.
Women are always going to be attracted to the alpha male because it is instinctual to know their children have a chance of surviving.
The dad that paints his nails at night, plucks his eyebrows and generally acts like a parody of a female would not last very long in a real life come to Jesus moment.
Gotta tell you? As a female I can kick some ass (because I had to not because I wanted to) but I want my man to put me to shame in that department not hide behind my skirts.
My point to all of this is that men and women aren’t interchangeable cogs. One’s personality has a much stronger influence on how they are at raising children then their sex. People are too different to make blanket assumption that a lack of father results in thugs. There are reasons why a two parent household is better than a single parent household in the raising of children not limited to it allowing each parent to spend more time with the kids and financial benefits of either having two incomes or not having to pay for childcare. But this idea that you need men to teach boys to be men and you need women to teach girls to be women has yet to be proven to me via any reliable data.