WSJ: "How Pediatricians Created the Peanut Allergy Epidemic" (A couple guys in lab coats ≠ "All science agrees on this.")

Sound familiar?

How Pediatricians Created the Peanut Allergy Epidemic

By recommending that children avoid exposure to peanuts until age 3, doctors inadvertently turned a rare issue into a major health problem.

". . . “What’s going on here?” Asonganyi asked. “We have no peanut allergies in Africa.”

I looked at them and smiled. “In Egypt, where my family is from, we don’t have peanut allergies either,” I said. “Welcome to America.”

Deaths from peanut allergies are real, and living with the problem can be terrifying. Compounding the tragedy is knowing that America’s epidemic of peanut allergies is a largely avoidable consequence of our policy of peanut abstinence.
.
.
.
What had changed wasn’t peanuts but the advice doctors gave to parents about them. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) wanted to respond to public concern by telling parents what they should do to protect their kids from peanut allergies. There was just one problem: Doctors didn’t actually know what precautions, if any, parents should take. Rather than admit that, in the year 2000 the AAP issued a recommendation for children 0 to 3 years old and pregnant and lactating mothers to avoid all peanuts.
.
.
.
When modern medicine issues recommendations based on good scientific studies, it shines. Conversely, when doctors rule by opinion and edict, we have an embarrassing track record. Unfortunately, medical dogma may be more prevalent today than in the past because intolerance for different opinions is on the rise, in medicine as throughout society.

Dr. Marty Makary is a surgeon and public health researcher at Johns Hopkins University. This essay is adapted from his new book, “Blind Spots: When Medicine Gets It Wrong, and What It Means for Our Health,” published by Bloomsbury.

https://www.wsj.com/health/how-pediatricians-created-the-peanut-allergy-epidemic-952831c4

2 Likes

Apparently after a handful of countries (the US and the UK are mentioned in the article), on very thin science, began recommending all pregnant mothers and all young children, should avoid peanuts peanut allergies in those countries skyrocketed.

In countries where no such recommendation was given the prevalence of peanut allergies remained right where it always had been, (just over one-half of one percent.)

Judging from the book’s dust cover

  • Dr Makarty’s book does not begin and end with peanut allegies, it delves into such topics as the rush to demonize animal fats (my words), blindness to the fact that overprescribing antibiotics really can cause a form of immunity to develop etc.
  • Nor does it attempt to demonize the pharma industry, or other big bad corporations. It instead focuses doctors who “rule by opinion and edict” and the fact that in today’s society dissenting opinions are less tolerated than they were in the recent past.

I’m taking a few courses now, but the book is on my reading list.

Dammit…start drinking out of the hose.

3 Likes
1 Like

at least they didn’t say peanuts caused global warming… Jimmy Carter was a peanut farmer

1 Like