First of all, this goes way beyond Trump. This anti-civil service crap is a product of populist bull ■■■■■ not conservatism.
After the assassination of President Garfield by a disappointed officer seeker, Congress passed the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act in 1883, ending the spoils system and establishing a permanent civil service system.
Towards the end of his administration, Trump signed an Executive Order creating a Schedule F to the Civil Service which would have stripped numerous Civil Service employees of protections. Fortunately, the enforcement of the order was held up by lawsuits and ultimately Trump was never able to remove anybody before he left office. Biden repealed the Executive Order during his first days in office.
Unfortunately, Trump and other populist clones have not give up on this stupid notion. Instead, they are doubling down on it, claiming a unitary executive theory gives the President the unfettered right to remove all 2,000,000+ civil service employees at will and replace them with his political hacks. In other words, a return to the failed and corrupt spoils system.
Under the Constitution, the President gets to appoint Principal Officers of the United States, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate. He gets to appoint certain Inferior Officers of the United States alone. Other Inferior Officers of the United States are appointed by Department and Agency heads or the Courts of Law. But since 1883, non officer Employees of the United States (other than the Excepted Service) have been hired, employed and fired by a merit process and are protected by law from removal or harassment by political appointees.
This should not change.
And even if it was changed, only Congress can do that by amending or repealing the Pendleton Act. The President cannot unilaterally deep six the Civil Service.
Yes, there is concern about bureaucratic interpretations of statute. Congress should respond by passing more narrowly focused detailed legislation, leaving less room for bureaucratic interpretation. Congress’s passage of broad and vague statutes is the genuine point of blame for things that are typically blamed on the so called “deep state.” Do a competent job of legislating and the “deep state” will have little to interpret.
My approach would be 100% the opposite. We should be reducing the number of Officers of the United States, both Principal and Inferior, as well as Excepted Service appointments. Currently, there are close to 9,000 positions of that type. We could and should cut that in half and more. There are thousands of positions in the Plum Book that can and should move from excepted service, non career service, etc. to career status. No other first world nation has anywhere near that number of political appointees.
I believe at a minimum, 500 Schedule C positions could be converted to Career. Plenty of other room to reduce the Excepted Service as well.
Now there ARE changes I would make, but they are aimed at making it easier to remove true deadweight from the Civil Service. The truly lazy and incompetent should be easier to fire.
-
Forbid union representation of any Career Civil Service worker. Career Civil Service have all the protections that unions are supposed to provide. They possess a solid grievance procedure that goes all the way to the Merit System Protection Board. Their pay and benefits are set by law. The only Civil Service workers who should be eligible for union representation are those without Merit System protection, such as TSA employees.
-
Streamline the disciplinary process so that problem employees can be identified and terminated within a matter of months, not several years as is often the case.
-
Establish at least a partial “up or out” system, so that a mediocre employee can’t simply ride to retirement over 20 years. I am not talking about a strict system, such as exists in the Foreign Service. But something that at least forces an employee to achieve at least a couple of promotions over 20 years in order to be carried to retirement. To use the example of the Armed Forces:
Air Force - you must reach E-5 to ride to 20 years
Army - E-6 for 20
Navy - E-6 for 20
Marines - E-6 for 20
Those last three changes are designed to improve the Civil Service. Removing Civil Service protections entirely would destroy the Civil Service.