What woman who transed into male has ever beaten the males for the medal or trophy? If it’s fair, as you’re attempting to indicate, then there should be just as many on both sides…50/50. So name one?
… or had those things. (And subsequently remodeled your body surgically and chemically.)
I inserted the reply you responded to.
These are not contradictory statements.
Even if someone honestly and sincerely thinks he’s the opposite sex, it still stands in opposition to the underlying biology.

There is a small % of people who are born with both genitials, or partial of both. If nature can make that physical type of a deviation, it is logical nature can deviate issues with the hormones and other attributes that make one a male or female.
And all of that is anomalous to normalcy.

Male and female are sexes
Gee a lib pretending to know what a woman is I’m sooooooo impressed.

The OP clearly lays that out. The boy pitched the games. The girl pitchers sat on the bench so that he could pitch. If he wasn’t on the team, girls would have pitched those games.
You don’t know that the other pitcher sat on the bench. They usually play multiple positions. She very well could be a star outfielder as well.

And please don’t insult my intelligence by saying the girls didn’t mind. I’m sure they didn’t join the team as a pitcher in order to sit on the bench while a boy pitched in their place.
They likely joined the team to be a part of a championship team. The team is very good. Even without Marissa.
They aren’t women. That’s for sure. And we shouldn’t fool ourselves into thinking they are.
But at the same time, they should be treated the same as any other citizen.

PurpnGold:
What woman is not able to compete because a trans woman competes?
What woman who transed into male has ever beaten the males for the medal or trophy? If it’s fair, as you’re attempting to indicate, then there should be just as many on both sides…50/50. So name one?
Mack Beggs
Keelin Godsey
Bobbi Hirsch
Patrico Manuel

Rodeo:
Zippy:
No. I sm saying “personal pronouns “ don’t exist.
The idea that people can choose their own pronouns along with the redefinition of various pronouns is a leftist construct designed to increase division among people.
Personal pronouns or preferred pronouns or whatever the kooks call them are a construct of the nutjob left.
You are male or female.
Libs have created all kinds of fun new words over the last few years to complicate the simplest concept in the world.
You are male or female.
Personally I find the whole “my pronouns are” thing to be disrespectful as hell to the rest of us and to the people who are actually he or she.
Male and female are sexes
Guys with a penis who identify as a woman still produce testosterone making them a biological male, your logic is flawed on why they should beat up women in boxing matches.

peek-a-boo:
The OP clearly lays that out. The boy pitched the games. The girl pitchers sat on the bench so that he could pitch. If he wasn’t on the team, girls would have pitched those games.
You don’t know that the other pitcher sat on the bench. They usually play multiple positions. She very well could be a star outfielder as well.
peek-a-boo:
And please don’t insult my intelligence by saying the girls didn’t mind. I’m sure they didn’t join the team as a pitcher in order to sit on the bench while a boy pitched in their place.
They likely joined the team to be a part of a championship team. The team is very good. Even without Marissa.
LOL Canady at Texas Tech pitched every game of the women’s softball World Series tournament, you can’t even lie honestly. No they don’t play other positions.

Smyrna:
PurpnGold:
What woman is not able to compete because a trans woman competes?
What woman who transed into male has ever beaten the males for the medal or trophy? If it’s fair, as you’re attempting to indicate, then there should be just as many on both sides…50/50. So name one?
Mack Beggs
Keelin Godsey
Bobbi Hirsch
Patrico Manuel
Lmao Beggs seriously? You think Imane Kelif would stand a chance against Errol Spence Jr another male? Two men literally fought one another for a women’s gold this past Olympics. You are disgusting.

Mack Beggs
Keelin Godsey
Bobbi Hirsch
Patrico Manuel
You truly are a waste of my time. You post women who think they’re men nonsense who beat women, not men in response to my question proving once again, there’s not even one example. Why do you choose to give dipwit responses? Don’t answer cuz we both know why.
Keelin Godsey (born Kelly Godsey, January 2, 1984) was the first openly transgender athlete to compete for a spot on the United States Olympic team.[1][2][3] Godsey was assigned female at birth, has openly identified as male (they/he) since 2005, and competed in women’s hammer throw competitions.

PurpnGold:
peek-a-boo:
The OP clearly lays that out. The boy pitched the games. The girl pitchers sat on the bench so that he could pitch. If he wasn’t on the team, girls would have pitched those games.
You don’t know that the other pitcher sat on the bench. They usually play multiple positions. She very well could be a star outfielder as well.
peek-a-boo:
And please don’t insult my intelligence by saying the girls didn’t mind. I’m sure they didn’t join the team as a pitcher in order to sit on the bench while a boy pitched in their place.
They likely joined the team to be a part of a championship team. The team is very good. Even without Marissa.
LOL Canady at Texas Tech pitched every game of the women’s softball World Series tournament, you can’t even lie honestly. No they don’t play other positions.
In HS softball they absolutely do. You have no idea what you are talking about.

PurpnGold:
Mack Beggs
Keelin Godsey
Bobbi Hirsch
Patrico ManuelYou truly are a waste of my time. You post women who think they’re men nonsense who beat women, not men in response to my question proving once again, there’s not even one example. Why do you choose to give dipwit responses? Don’t answer cuz we both know why.
![]()
Keelin Godsey (born Kelly Godsey, January 2, 1984) was the first openly transgender athlete to compete for a spot on the United States Olympic team.[1][2][3] Godsey was assigned female at birth, has openly identified as male (they/he) since 2005, and competed in women’s hammer throw competitions.
What?
Only Mack Beggs was forced to compete with women. The other three competed with Men.

What?
Only Mack Beggs was forced to compete with women. The other three competed with Men.
…and you can’t read either. Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice. Just stop.

PurpnGold:
What?
Only Mack Beggs was forced to compete with women. The other three competed with Men.
…and you can’t read either. Niiiiiiiiiiiiiiiice. Just stop.
Oh
And Keelin competed with women.

What?
Only Mack Beggs was forced to compete with women. The other three competed with Men.
So I went to the next name and wasted more time…just trying to give you some credibility?
The 19-year-old from Huntington Woods fenced on Wayne State’s women’s team as a freshman last school year. This school year, the sophomore is fencing on the university’s men’s team.
So this is the first year competing against men and has won no titles or trophies beating them. Once again…you’ve wasted my time.

They likely joined the team to be a part of a championship team. The team is very good. Even without Marissa.
Cut the crap. They joined the team to play on the team. Not to watch a boy play on their team in their place.

You don’t know that the other pitcher sat on the bench. They usually play multiple positions. She very well could be a star outfielder as well.
You really are grasping. If I’m a girl pitcher, I want to pitch. Not sit on the bench or play second base while a boy is allowed to pitch in my place.
No matter how much you try to spin this, boys being allowed to play on a girls’ team is just plain sick.

PurpnGold:
What?
Only Mack Beggs was forced to compete with women. The other three competed with Men.
So I went to the next name and wasted more time…just trying to give you some credibility?
The 19-year-old from Huntington Woods fenced on Wayne State’s women’s team as a freshman last school year. This school year, the sophomore is fencing on the university’s men’s team.
So this is the first year competing against men and has won no titles or trophies beating them. Once again…you’ve wasted my time.
Why do championships and medals matter in your argument? Are saying you are ok with transwomen playing with woman so long as they don’t win a medal or championship?