Yes, even after committing misdemeanors (up to 3). As long as they meet the right illegal conditions.
Thereâs little evidence for what you fear.
And you deal with it by making it part of comprehensive reform, not making it harder on people who have pretty much been here all their lives.
You seem to having an issue following the plot here.
Speaking comprehensive immigration reform, if thatâs passed, it needs to be a felony to be in the country illegally, and the punishment is immediate deportation. Otherwise weâre roght back in the same boat in a decade.
You seem to having an issue following the plot here.
Just saying itâs hard to get deported while covered under DACA.
Ok.
How does that relate to the conversation we were having?
Ok.
How does that relate to the conversation we were having?
Just a little side trip highlighting some of the other perks they get.
I asked what should be required of them on this âpathway to citizenshipâ but nobody seems able to give me an answer.
So what should be required of them? Iâm not hearing any specifics from anybody.
Dream Act legislation has been continually proposed since Dubya was first elected. Though I havenât kept up on the particulars of the latest editions, I expect most any of them would be acceptable to me.
I asked what should be required of them on this âpathway to citizenshipâ but nobody seems able to give me an answer.
Well, thatâs a policy question. A lot of criteria have been suggested.
Military service/college degrees, 5 year wait for a green card, another 5 to apply for citizenship was the DREAM Act standard, I think.
Mountain_Soldier:I asked what should be required of them on this âpathway to citizenshipâ but nobody seems able to give me an answer.
Well, thatâs a policy question. A lot of criteria have been suggested.
Military service/college degrees, 5 year wait for a green card, another 5 to apply for citizenship was the DREAM Act standard, I think.
And if they fail to meet any of those requirements?
Trump isnât offering them amnesty. Heâs offering them a three year extension so he can use them as a bargaining chip again.
So in other words, theyâre hostages.
I answered. You ignored it. Itâs okay to not respond, but donât pretend it didnât happe.
Then they donât become citizens.
Then they donât become citizens.
But get to stay.
Well, no. If they donât meet those qualifications, theyâre in the same legal situation as any other illegal immigrant.
I answered. You ignored it. Itâs okay to not respond, but donât pretend it didnât happe.
Where is it? I apologize if I missed it.
Well, no. If they donât meet those qualifications, theyâre in the same legal situation as any other illegal immigrant.
Even though this is the only country theyâve ever known?
As the law is written, yes.
A pathway to citizenship varies from proposal to proposal. The DREAM act from back in 2001 required them to serve in the military or go to college in order to get a green card. Other proposals just make them get background checks, stay out of jail, pay fines and taxes to get permanent residence. I think itâs at least five years from green card to being able to apply for citizenship but donât quote me on that. People lose their permanent residence all the time and are deported. Itâs not new.
Thanks.
Which of those are tenable to Democrats now?