The impeachment article about abuse of power involved Trump’s allegedly partisan pressure on Ukraine to investigate allegations of corruption involving Trump’s political opponent, Joe Biden. Assuming Nancy Pelosi eventually sends the impeachment to the senate, several Democratic presidential candidates will in judgement of President Trump, who is arguably their political opponent.
Based on the apparent conflict of interest, should all the Democratic candidates recuse themselves?
If they don’t, are they guilty of abuse of power based on the same logic used in the impeachment articles?
For background, Karl Rove brought up a similar question in a recent commentary:
"Mr. Booker himself, a little hypocritical, has already said months and months ago ‘impeach President Trump.’ When are we going to hear Booker denounce himself and denounce Warren, and denounce Sanders, and denounce Kamalah Harris and denounce Amy Klobuchar as being biased and incapable of serving on the jury?
It is an interesting question…And it can go other way with the GOP Senators who said they wont be fair and impartial. I believe they have to take another oath saying otherwise before the Senate trial…
Democrats have been saying the impeachment and removal from office does not require actual proof of violations of the criminal code.
Senators can be removed from office by 2/3 majority in the Senate. That does not require proof of a criminal offense either. Will Democrats support removal of senators who refuse to recuse themselves?
Based on what legal president? If it isn’t in the Constitution I don’t see how a legal case can be made.
It would have to go to the courts and would most probably end up in the SCOTUS.
The precedent is based on the language of the impeachment articles themselves. If supporting an investigation of a political opponent is corruption worthy of impeachment, then logically sitting in judgement in a trial to remove a political opponent from the office you are seeking is at least as corrupt.
Only one of them (or maybe someone else) will be the candidate. But you are wanting all of the ones running to recuse. That seems pretty unfair. How about we wait until the candidate is chosen and if that person is a Senator then it could be considered? But hey, it’s sort of a moot point anyway since none of it is going to happen.