I’m going to also include the ones who were not elected and not include Kennedy since he died while in office.
George H.W. Bush - Best
Hoover
Johnson
Carter
Harding
Ford
Dump - worst
Bush - Elected as a continuation of Reagan. Was hero for first Gulf War. Economy, looking at his watch during debate, and Perot/Clinton’s coolness were Bush’s downfall
Carter - Was elected as backlash to the whole Nixon pardon by Ford. Was lost on foreign affairs. Iran hostages and sinking economy didn’t help. Reagan’s charisma was strong.
Hoover - Was Coolidge’s selection to keep US going. Failed to recognize everything falling around him.
Trump - Result of Hillary backlash. Kept promises on judges, and was decent on foreign affairs. Clearly failed on COVID-19.
I could care less about their personalities, though Trump’s did amuse me to no end. I’ve seen worse personalities than his who were the most effective military leaders I’ll ever know. If the economy was in the tank and al-Qaeda 7.0 was rampaging through the cradle of civilization, I’d have H.W. Bush in the favorite slot.