Justice Department threatens executive privilege over entire Mueller report

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T00:51:13.879Z

Yes (if you’re being serious).

For instance, congress has the enumerated power to “lay and collect taxes.” It would be difficult to do so without an agency to collect (IRS), consequences for tax fraud, or the ability to write a tax code. Those would be necessary and proper implied powers needed to carry out the enumerated powers.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T00:53:06.284Z

SottoVoce:

Yes (if you’re being serious).

For instance, congress has the enumerated power to “lay and collect taxes.” It would be difficult to do so without an agency to collect (IRS), consequences for tax fraud, or the ability to write a tax code. Those would be necessary and proper implied powers needed to carry out the enumerated powers.

Ok, I’m with you. But I want to know where this concept of “oversight” comes in?

Roxiebelle · 2019-05-09T01:20:25.118Z

JayJay:

Yep and Obama got pilloried for doing that…remember?

On what planet? Certainly not here on earth!

JayJay · 2019-05-09T01:44:18.633Z

Roxiebelle:

JayJay:

Yep and Obama got pilloried for doing that…remember?

On what planet? Certainly not here on earth!

Unlike you, I remember history as it actually happened.

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T01:57:00.570Z

In the simplest way I can think of (no knock on you, just trying to keep of simple).

The power of the legislature is to write law, pass budgets, etc. Those laws and other mandates created by the legislature then go to the executive branch to enact. The legislature has oversight powers to ensure those laws, etc are being lawfully enacted.

Kevhead · 2019-05-09T02:26:34.632Z

Where is executive privilege

DOLOOP · 2019-05-09T02:29:37.058Z

conan:

Then why haven’t they?

It is not unredacted and it does not include the underlying evidence.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T14:24:46.727Z

SottoVoce:

In the simplest way I can think of (no knock on you, just trying to keep of simple).

The power of the legislature is to write law, pass budgets, etc. Those laws and other mandates created by the legislature then go to the executive branch to enact. The legislature has oversight powers to ensure those laws, etc are being lawfully enacted.

Ok, Where is that power in the Constitution?

WuWei · 2019-05-09T14:27:22.760Z

Kevhead:

Where is executive privilege

It’s not. Just like the power for Congress to obtain the documents is not.

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T14:35:05.899Z

Went over that. Implied power based on enumerated powers.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T16:36:58.741Z

SottoVoce:

Went over that. Implied power based on enumerated powers.

and who “implied” it?

Do you see the self-licking ice cream cone?

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T16:46:21.958Z

The Constitution did.

Google “implied powers.” You’ll fine better examples and explanation than I can give.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T16:46:57.524Z

SottoVoce:

Google “implied powers.” You’ll fine better examples and explanation than I can give.

Where?
I’m not discussing this with google.

wiley8425 · 2019-05-09T17:00:29.201Z

“Ok, Where is that power in the Constitution?”

The same place Judicial Review is. The same place Executive Privilege is. The same place National Security is. The same place our Government run amok is. Nowhere. Time for another Revolution.

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T17:11:29.508Z

Necessary and proper clause.

Example. IRS. IRS is part of executive branch (part of Department of Treasury). Congress writes tax code which goes to IRS to enforce. Necessary and proper clause gives Congress the power to monitor IRS (oversight) to make sure their enumerated power (taxation) is appropriately performed. This includes inspection of individual tax returns to verify the tax code they passed is being properly enforced.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T17:25:36.421Z

SottoVoce:

Necessary and proper clause.

Example. IRS. IRS is part of executive branch (part of Department of Treasury). Congress writes tax code which goes to IRS to enforce. Necessary and proper clause gives Congress the power to monitor IRS (oversight) to make sure their enumerated power (taxation) is appropriately performed. This includes inspection of individual tax returns to verify the tax code they passed is being properly enforced.

Good Lord that’s a stretch.

SottoVoce · 2019-05-09T17:59:21.884Z

A stretch save for the centuries of precedent.

CaughtInTheMiddle · 2019-05-09T18:16:00.970Z

SottoVoce:

Necessary and proper clause.

Example. IRS. IRS is part of executive branch (part of Department of Treasury). Congress writes tax code which goes to IRS to enforce. Necessary and proper clause gives Congress the power to monitor IRS (oversight) to make sure their enumerated power (taxation) is appropriately performed. This includes inspection of individual tax returns to verify the tax code they passed is being properly enforced.

Donald Trump appears to have more groupies than Russell Westbrook and Stormy Daniels combined.

WuWei · 2019-05-09T18:20:32.648Z

SottoVoce:

A stretch save for the centuries of precedent.

You can do it wrong for 1,000 years, don’t make it right.

Who decided the Constitution “implies” this?

WuWei · 2019-05-09T18:21:07.327Z

SottoVoce:

A stretch save for the centuries of precedent.

So drift into failure?