Australians should not be allowed in the US.
I think all of the state sanctioned gambling has gone too far.
Was OK with a few scratch offs and a single state mega lottery.
Now PA is a gambling kingpin.
FloridaYankee: SixFoot:When someone wins the American Powerball, theyâre also Americans. Foreigners have no business being a part of it.
Should you show proof of citizenship when you walk into a store and buy a ticket?
Australians should not be allowed in the US.
Uh huh. On what legal grounds?
WuWei: FloridaYankee: SixFoot:When someone wins the American Powerball, theyâre also Americans. Foreigners have no business being a part of it.
Should you show proof of citizenship when you walk into a store and buy a ticket?
Australians should not be allowed in the US.
Uh huh. On what legal grounds?
Weâll have to pass a law.
FloridaYankee: WuWei: FloridaYankee: SixFoot:When someone wins the American Powerball, theyâre also Americans. Foreigners have no business being a part of it.
Should you show proof of citizenship when you walk into a store and buy a ticket?
Australians should not be allowed in the US.
Uh huh. On what legal grounds?
Weâll have to pass a law.
How does it pass constitutional muster?
How does it pass constitutional muster?
Theyâre foreigners, if we keep them out, the Constitution doesnât apply to them.
FloridaYankee:How does it pass constitutional muster?
Theyâre foreigners, if we keep them out, the Constitution doesnât apply to them.
After all the trouble Trump had banning foreigners from terrorist supporting countries, barely getting it by the SCOTUS, Iâm not seeing a legal pathway to this.
Trump was racist. We have Jbiden now.
Living here Iâd like to see the math on it before I decide if itâs good or bad decision.
For example, how much money typically leaves the state due to powerball vs how much comes into the state due to it.
If say: 10million a year typically get spent on powerball, but only 1 million in winnings enters, then canceling it will be a net positive to the economy. Canceling it will still be a negative on collected taxes.
Living here Iâd like to see the math on it before I decide if itâs good or bad decision.
For example, how much money typically leaves the state due to powerball vs how much comes into the state due to it.
If say: 10million a year typically get spent on powerball, but only 1 million in winnings enters, then canceling it will be a net positive to the economy. Canceling it will still be a negative on collected taxes.
The article points out that PowerBall generates a positive net revenue of $28 million year with $14 million of that going into funding public schools.
WW
Steel-W0LF:Living here Iâd like to see the math on it before I decide if itâs good or bad decision.
For example, how much money typically leaves the state due to powerball vs how much comes into the state due to it.
If say: 10million a year typically get spent on powerball, but only 1 million in winnings enters, then canceling it will be a net positive to the economy. Canceling it will still be a negative on collected taxes.
The article points out that PowerBall generates a positive net revenue of $28 million year with $14 million of that going into funding public schools.
WW
Thatâs not exactly what Iâm asking.
Iâm asking how much do residents spend on powerball tickets that then leaves our economy vs how much enters our economy.
Basically. If I remember correctly most Powerball purchasers come from the people who have the least money. How much money is leaving the poor economy vs how much winnings is entering it.
Yes I agree that itâs a benefit to the tax revenue the state collects.
That much money going to public schools and its turning out students who eat tide pods. Seems like a waste of money
Steel-W0LF:Living here Iâd like to see the math on it before I decide if itâs good or bad decision.
For example, how much money typically leaves the state due to powerball vs how much comes into the state due to it.
If say: 10million a year typically get spent on powerball, but only 1 million in winnings enters, then canceling it will be a net positive to the economy. Canceling it will still be a negative on collected taxes.
The article points out that PowerBall generates a positive net revenue of $28 million year with $14 million of that going into funding public schools.
WW
By essentially taxing the poor.
So all state sponsored gambling should be canceled.
Is that your stance?
Do you really want the state to have the power to tell you what you can and cannot do?
What happened to freedom.
I guess itâs only for some issues.
Allan
The majority of people who play, canât afford to and the money theyâve played with comes at the expense of those depending on it. Itâs almost like there are many drug addicts so the government sells them drugs to make money but at their personal expense.
Ours also goes to veterans.
biggestal99:So all state sponsored gambling should be canceled.
Is that your stance?
Do you really want the state to have the power to tell you what you can and cannot do?
What happened to freedom.
I guess itâs only for some issues.
Allan
The majority of people who play, canât afford to and the money theyâve played with comes at the expense of those depending on it. Itâs almost like there are many drug addicts so the government sells them drugs to make money but at their personal expense.
So what? If they canât afford to play, they should stop. Itâs not mandatory.
By essentially taxing the poor.
Sin tax.
Just like alcohol and cigarettes.
Are we gonna stop selling those too.
Allan
So what? If they canât afford to play, they should stop. Itâs not mandatory.
People donât need to drink alcohol or smoke cigarettes either.
Poor people buy those too.
Letâs bring prohibition back, it worked out so well the first time around.
Allan
Letâs see. "Weâre going to set up a program whereby you can donate $10 at a time to help the education system and vets.
And as a carrot, weâre going to offer you a slim chance to win $1M or more."
Orrrr
âWe can just raise your taxes to help education and vets and you can do without the slim chance.â
Lottery is an ask. We should encourage asking instead of telling.
Lottery is an ask. We should encourage asking instead of telling.
Sin taxes are all asks.
Allan