I had an interesting call, today

Call_me_Ishmael · 2018-07-06T21:06:47.931Z

was watching a civil war movie the other day. I wondered about how they did it back then.

DMK · 2018-07-06T21:08:07.059Z

Did you verify this was a call from the Defense Department? I’d be rather wary of giving out my DNA.

mwevans1234 · 2018-07-06T21:12:12.259Z

That’s interesting! What are your thoughts/feelings on the matter? To make it political and have a home here, there’s a resource investment to make this program happen. One of the main intended benefits (I’d think), in addition to honoring the deceased, is to provide closure, pride, etc. to family members - so curious as to your thoughts!

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:18:57.865Z

DMK:

Did you verify this was a call from the Defense Department? I’d be rather wary of giving out my DNA.

I verified it. The calling number was from the Genealogical firm the DoD has contracted with to find the families. I looked it up.
She said the Army would contact me within 60 days to arrange to do the test.

LouC · 2018-07-06T21:29:00.713Z

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:32:28.914Z

mwevans1234:

That’s interesting! What are your thoughts/feelings on the matter? To make it political and have a home here, there’s a resource investment to make this program happen. One of the main intended benefits (I’d think), in addition to honoring the deceased, is to provide closure, pride, etc. to family members - so curious as to your thoughts!

I think it is commendable. I think “we bring our soldiers home” is a noble goal.
It’s taking them a lot of time and expenditure to run this program and I appreciate it.

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:35:32.607Z

LouC:

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

This uncle was also in the Bataan Death March. He survived the march and died in the prison a few months later.

LouC · 2018-07-06T21:38:38.544Z

Call_me_Ishmael:

was watching a civil war movie the other day. I wondered about how they did it back then.

Good question. According to the Military only about 60% of Civil War soldier fatalities, both in the field and from hospitals, were ever properly identified.

I was surprised the number was that high after seeing the early images from so many of those conflicts of that war, the carnage, the total overwhelming nature of so many dead and wounded without the infrastructure to handle it.

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:40:39.313Z

LouC:

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

Your wife may be getting one of those calls. Is she now the next of kin?

LouC · 2018-07-06T21:40:50.852Z

BillBrown:

LouC:

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

This uncle was also in the Bataan Death March. He survived the march and died in the prison a few months later.

Wow.

Who knows, perhaps he knew my wife’s uncle?

Sort of chilling.

LouC · 2018-07-06T21:43:12.397Z

Her and her older surviving brother.

He is in the same city where the uncle’s remains were returned.

I will have to make her aware of this!

Thanks.

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:44:15.173Z

LouC:

BillBrown:

LouC:

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

This uncle was also in the Bataan Death March. He survived the march and died in the prison a few months later.

Wow.

Who knows, perhaps he knew my wife’s uncle?

Sort of chilling.

There were 60,000 - 80,000 men, from 7 different camps in that march. But yes- they might have known each other.

LouC · 2018-07-06T21:45:24.958Z

BillBrown:

LouC:

BillBrown:

LouC:

Perhaps they are trying to confirm proper reunifications have been performed. It is not uncommon that remains have been incorrectly distributed.

Just another sad and tragic aspect of war.

That the DOD takes this so seriously is a plus, even if there is potential for reopening wounds. I applaud the effort.

My wife’s uncle died in the Bataan Death March in WWII.

His “remains” were returned after the war and she vaguely remembers the funeral for him, no body. but she has wonderd how they were so certain it was him?

This uncle was also in the Bataan Death March. He survived the march and died in the prison a few months later.

Wow.

Who knows, perhaps he knew my wife’s uncle?

Sort of chilling.

There were 60,000 - 80,000 men, from 7 different camps in that march. But yes- they might have known each other.

Sometimes this big old world is just that small.

mwevans1234 · 2018-07-06T21:47:01.562Z

BillBrown:

I think it is commendable. I think “we bring our soldiers home” is a noble goal.
It’s taking them a lot of time and expenditure to run this program and I appreciate it.

I agree! Certainly worse ways to spend tax dollars…

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T21:48:18.032Z

LouC:

Her and her older surviving brother.

He is in the same city where the uncle’s remains were returned.

I will have to make her aware of this!

Thanks.

Here is the DoD website about this program. There is a lot of info, including huge lists of names of servicemen they are trying to find the families of.

https://dpaa.secure.force.com/dpaaFamWeb

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T22:14:01.525Z

I’m glad my mother isn’t here to see this. She was very emotional about her brother’s death even after so many years had passed.
She would be very upset to learn that he wasn’t buried in that grave.

DMK · 2018-07-06T22:42:42.345Z

BillBrown:

I verified it. The calling number was from the Genealogical firm the DoD has contracted with to find the families. I looked it up.
She said the Army would contact me within 60 days to arrange to do the test.

Okay, good to hear. You are a good man to follow through with this.

WuWei · 2018-07-06T22:49:19.127Z

Those guys never stop working. The JPRA and JCRC (they’ve probably changed the names) are truly unsung heroes in my book. They just keep grinding away and never get enough credit.

WuWei · 2018-07-06T22:50:51.736Z

Be quiet.
…

BillBrown · 2018-07-06T23:30:04.315Z

WuWei:

Those guys never stop working. The JPRA and JCRC (they’ve probably changed the names) are truly unsung heroes in my book. They just keep grinding away and never get enough credit.

They call themself the DPAA - Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency